Click here for Back Issues of the Post Mortem

To submit an article for consideration, click Here.

 Tough hands or funny stories are always welcom

May 2008

 

Return to Top

 

 

Return to Top

Return to Top

 

Return to Top

 
 

INTERNET POST

By Arlene Port

 

You are South,  IMPS, None Vulnerable

Here is your hand:

S - 8
H -  Q 5 4
D - A 10 9 8 4
C - K 6 4 2
 
The Bidding is:
SOUTH WEST NORTH EAST
--- --- --- PASS
PASS 1 H PASS 4 H
PASS PASS DBL PASS
???      

What do you bid?

Asim Ulke: 5D Partner should have a 4-0-4-5 distribution. Diamonds are as good as any. East probably has a singleton, I don't want him to lead it. Furthermore, if opponents compete to 5H, I want partner to lead a diamond. So I bid 5D.

Mary Carns: 4NT- Pick a minor.  Usually, there would be only 2 reasons that partner might pass originally, then double 4H.  Either he has hearts (impossible from the bidding and my hand), or he has a takeout double without spades--Almost impossible from the bidding and my hand.  I think he has a good hand with 4 spades and one long minor.  Most likely distribution 4-1-6-2 (with 4-1-5-3 he should double originally).  His minor should be diamonds since he could correct 5C by me--but if it is clubs, what is he planning to do over 5D?  But, rather than bid 5D unilaterally, I make the safety bid in case he passed originally with 4-1-2-6 and now got stuck..

Roni Atkins: Pass - I really have nothing to bid and think that we will set 4H

Herb Sachs: 5D I expect my partner to be at worst 4-4-4-1 and maybe better. I bid my best suit.

PJ Prabu: 5D My first thought was to bid 4NT, asking partner to pick a minor, should he be 5=0=3=5. But then, why didn't he overcall 2H? Or 1S, 2NT, or double 1H, for that matter? Hope he is 5=0=4=4 with weak S. T9xxx,-,Kxxx,AQxx would be ideal.

Bill Holt: I pass.  I am risking 170 (590 versus 420) but I think we have a better chance of beating 4H than of making 5m.  Partner is some 40(54) who could not act over 1H.  Sounds too soft for 9 tricks to me (down 2 in 5mX), I'd rather try to take 4.  I hope to lead my singleton spade out of turn and get away with it.

Richard Katz: 5D My partner is probably 4-0-4-5 or 4-0-5-4. He doesn’t have spades because he didn’t overcall. So, I bid my best suit.

Bruce Keidan: 4NT. Pick a minor. But if he passes, maybe I'll make it. I'd love to know partner's hand for this auction.

Jim Bachelder: 4NT!  LHO has opened a Flanneryish (maybe KXXX, AKXXX, X, XXX) hand and partner has the "best hand at the table" without 4 spades.  RHO is clearly preempting with a Yarborough (something like" XXXXX, JXXX, XXX, X. Partner didn't double originally due to the spade flaw but is doubling now to keep spades in focus should I have length in the suit. Partner holds something like: AQX, X, KQXX, AQXXX.and we may be cold for slam but I'll settle for game because the Ace and King of spades might be reversed. That's what preempts are about.

Trudy Cohn: I bid 4 NT asking partner to bid his best minor suit. Partner probably has four spades and a longer minor suit.

Ernie Retetagos: 5 Diamonds. Strange auction. I think partner has a weak 4-4-5. This save might even have chance to make
 

 

 

 


Internet Post Results:

 

Bid:

NAT'L PGH AWARD
4NT 11 4 100
5D 9 5 90
PASS 14 2 80
       
       
       
 

 

HOW THE NATIONAL
EXPERTS VOTED
 
See next page - below!
   
 

Return to Top

Return to Top

 

Return to Top

 

 

Return to Top

 

Top of Page

Hit Counter